The Crofter & the Laird -PaperbackThe Crofter and the Laird
Published by Farrar, Straus & Giroux
Hardcover: 0-374-13192-9; $
Paperback: 0-374-51465-8; $12.00US

The Crofter and the Laird, a depiction of a small Scottish island, its terrain, its history, its legends, and its present people (two in particular--the crofter, working out his existence in this last domain of the feudal system, and the laird, who is English and owns the whole island and in a sense owns everyone on it). John McPhee had his own reasons for going there, and he gives them as the book begins:, a depiction of a small Scottish island, its terrain, its history, its legends, and its present people (two in particular--the crofter, working out his existence in this last domain of the feudal system, and the laird, who is English and owns the whole island and in a sense owns everyone on it). John McPhee had his own reasons for going there, and he gives them as the book begins:

The Scottish clan that I belong to--or would belong to if it were now anything more than a sentimental myth--was broken a great many generations ago by a party of MacDonalds, who hunted down the last chief of my clan, captured him, refused him mercy, saying that a man who had never shown mercy should not ask for it, tied him to a standing stone, and shot him. The standing stone was in a place called Balaromin Mor, on Colonsay, a small island in the open Atlantic, twenty-five miles west of the Scottish mainland…sole territory of a small clan, never more than a few hundred people, whose title to the island had come by immemorial occupation.

…Not long ago, it occurred to me that although all my clansmen in America had talked for so long about Colonsay, as far as I knew none of them had ever been there. For that matter, all that I knew about it was that it was one of the Hebrides, in the islands of Argyll. As soon as I could, I took my wife and our four young daughters and went to live for a while on Colonsay.

Donald McNeill's father, Gilbert McNeill, worked the same croft, and so did his father, Donald McNeill, and his father, Gilbert McNeill, and his father, Donald McNeill. In each of these generations were siblings who emigrated to the mainland or to America, and sometimes everybody in the family went except the one who stayed with the croft. Donald has one brother, and he is now a policeman in Dunbartonshire. Donald once had a calendar on his kitchen wall that showed, in irresistible color, the mountain forests of British Columbia. It was Donald's wife--Margaret MacMillan MacArthur McNeill--who put the calendar there, and even before its time had run out she knew that her daydreams of British Columbia were aimless ones, because Donald would never leave Colonsay.

There are seventeen crofts on Colonsay and seven farms (a farm has more than forty-nine tillable acres), and a hundred and thirty-eight people, of two castes. About eighty are islanders, like the McNeills and the rest are incomers. The incomers, for the most part, are people who were born on the mainland or on other islands or whose fathers or grandfathers were born on the mainland or on other islands. What constitutes an islander apparently, is a familial history of unbroken residence on Colonsay for two or three hundred years. The islanders, for the most part, are crofters and farmers. The incomers are the doctor, the postman, the postmaster, the schoolteacher, the innkeeper, the storekeeper, the minister--the permanently unestablished establishment.

The school day begins at nine-thirty--in a low, gray, roughcast building that has only one classroom. The hour is so late because of the distances that some of the children have to travel. Wee Ian, of Balnahard, whose age is twelve, has to drive a tractor three and a half miles to a point where the school bus can pick him up.

The doctor, tall and spare, is a thinker, and his mind drifts. As he neared the laird's farm in his Land-Rover, his thoughts were far, far away. After a long straight stretch, the road takes a hairpin turn to the left, and there the doctor made a slight right.

The usual frictions, gossip, and intense social espionage that characterize life in a small town are so grandly magnified on Colonsay that they sometimes appear in surprising form, in the way that patches of skin magnified a hundred diameters may appear to be landscapes of the moon. Air and water, sea and sky, life is imploded upon the people here by the blue bottle that surrounds them. Everyone is many things to everyone else, and is encountered daily in a dozen guises. Enmeshed together, the people of the island become one another. Friend and enemy dwell in the same skin.

Under the brooding absence of the laird, there are great men here, within their context--masters, for a few pounds' rent a year, of considerable domains, with an independence that must go beyond any usual sense of that word elsewhere, except on another remote small island. Donald Garvard--who is a big and powerful man, with speckled skin and a handsome, weathered face--strides alongside his two dozen beef cattle in a heavy mist on the grasslands of Balaromin Mor…

Ross Darroch is an uncompromising companion when he is having a dram at the pub. "Have a drink," he says, and if Neil or anyone else says no, Ross says, "You're going to have a drink!" Neil sometimes picks Ross up and tosses him into another part of the room.

The laird is younger than nearly all the men who have come to pay him their money and their respects. He is good-looking, tall, athletic, a bit heavy in the cheek, with long swept-back straight hair, amusement in his eyes, and the accents of Eton and Cambridge in his voice.

"The laird is an evil man in several senses of the word."

"As a boy, he took his sweets off and ate them by himself in the woods."

"That, I should say, is characteristic of him today."

"Mean, parsimonious, close-fisted is the laird.

The Crofter & the Laird - HardcoverThe laird, with his legs stretched out, is sitting, sipping whisky, on a low bench before a log fire at Colonsay House in late evening, his wife beside him. He has been considering, with only minor signs of emotion, the fact that he is the least popular man on the island he owns.

The book ends with a section on the early life of the island clan, its chiefs and tanisters, involving elements on both sides of the thin partition that separates superstition and fact in the Hebrides.

Reviews

McPhee brings to his book about the island of Colonsay in the Scottish Hebrides a visual precision and a grace of language that are quite rare. --Harper's

A small masterpiece of penetrating warmth and perception. --Charles Eliot, Time

One always has the sense with McPhee of a man at a pitch of pleasure in his work, a natural at it, finding out on behalf of the rest of us how some portion of the world works. --Edward Hoagland, The New York Times


Home | John McPhee | Bookshelf | About FSG | Other FSG Websites

Copyright ©2000 - 2003 Farrar, Straus & Giroux
Designed by FSB Associates